In citing the war, he was simply taking advantage of the fact that the war was a particularly unpopular one in the north. Obligations are unevenly present in any political order because, he says, consents are not uniform. He was a good friend of various literary figures of the day, including ralph waldo emerson, one of the most eminent of american authors and a popular orator. When there is an established process of election to an office, then, provided the election is free, anyone who takes part in the process consents to the author. Political obligation and civil disobedience edward a. Bickel at what point, asks john rawls in his celebrated recent book, a theory of justice, to which i shall make further reference, does the duty to comply with laws enacted by a legislative majority. Social, political, and legal philosophy volume 77 april 1967 number 3 the obligation to disobey michael walzer according to liberal political the ory, as first formulated by john locke, any individual citizen, oppressed by the rulers of the state, has a right to disobey their commands, break their laws, even rebel and seek. Civil disobedience and other essays download civil disobedience and other essays ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub, and mobi format. I then develop a symmetrical account of the disobedience involved in acts of civil disobedience.
However, in considering the behaviour of a virtuous civil disobedient. Civil disobedience people, or they are commitments to principles or parties or political institutions that arouse expecta tions in other people. Delmas argues that disobedience is entirely of a piece with these obligations. A deliberate act of law breaking to protest a law or governmental policy that is regarded as immoral.
Wellman has recently offered a samaritan account of state legitimacy and political obligation, according to which the state is justified in coercing each citizen in order to rescue all. Essay on civil disobedience 1 essay on civil disobedience henry david thoreau henry david thoreau 18171862 was a citizen of. On the assumption that people have a pro tanto obligation to follow the law or at least those laws that are not excessively unjust, it follows that people then have a pro tanto obligation to use the proper legal channels of political participation before resorting to illegal methods. Power university of cincinnati theoretical discussions of civil disobedience. Pdf civil disobedience, climate protests and a rawlsian. Historically, civil disobedience has been used since biblical times. Political obligation stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Motto in civil disobedience, thoreau society bulletin, 67. Perfect prep for civil disobedience quizzes and tests you might have in school. Rawlss account continues to be oriented by the underlying notion that the legitimate exercise of coercive political power must be justifiable on terms that persons subject to that power can affirm on due reflection. Civil disobedience and conscientious objection are distinct but related social practices that display peoples opposition to specific laws, policies, directives, or schemes. In a recent article on civil disobedience, hugo bedau has denied. Eventually, whatever the will of the sovereign is, becomes your will.
How can we justify from a moral point of view an act of civil disobedience. It highlights the following gap between theory and practice. This project is based on the first two chapters of the book i am currently completing, duty to disobey. Trade and commerce, if they were not made of india rubber,3 would never manage to bounce over the obstacles which legislators are continually putting in their way.
Civil disobedience and political obligation uk essays. Civil disobedience is the active, professed refusal of a citizen to obey certain laws of the state, and or demands, orders, and commands of a government, or of an occupying international power. Henry david thoreau 18171862 was a citizen of concord, massachusetts, where he lived during the middle of the 19th century. Civil disobedience is an effective way for there to be. Rawls discusses two instances in which certain forms of resistance are justifiable. The two chief virtues of social institu tions are justice and efficiency, where by the efficiency of institutions i under. Even proponents of civil disobedience generally hold that, given this moral duty, breaking the law requires justification. For many of those engaging in civil disobedience this act of breaking the law is demanded of them not only by their h3 belief in their own moral reasoning but also by a compliance with moral consistency and by their perception of the interests of the society they are part of. Insofar as civil disobedience theory assumes that political resistance requires.
To have a political obligation is to have a moral duty to obey the laws of ones country or state. Jun 18, 2014 in this paper, i defend the existence of a moral duty to disobey the law and engage in civil disobedience on the basis of one of the grounds of political obligationthe samaritan duty. On a moral right to civil disobedience david lefkowitz in this essay i argue that citizens of a liberaldemocratic state, one that i argue has a morally justi. Civil disobedience and the duty to obey yale law school. Civil disobedience and conscientious objection oxford. The phenomenon is interpreted with selected ideas from the study of political obligation and unconventional dissent. On that point there is almost complete agreement among political philosophers. The introduction uses the freedom rides to set up the books discussion of our responsibilities in the face of injustice. The phrase political obligation is apparently no older than t.
Nov 15, 2019 while delmas contributions to the literature on civil disobedience are obvious, her arguments about political obligation are equally significant. It is because acts associated with civil disobedience are. But for dissenters outside of the administration, civil disobedience is the weapon of choice. Click download or read online button to civil disobedience and other essays book pdf for free now.
I then discuss and reject three objections to my argument. Thoreaus critique of democracy in civil disobedience a close reading guide from america in class 3 all, marching in admirable order over hill and dale to the wars, against their wills, ay, against their common sense and consciences, which makes it very steep marching indeed, and produces a palpitation of the heart. Thoreaus critique of democracy in civil disobedience. Civil disobedience stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. In twentiethcentury political theory the term civil disobedience is fre. Throughout history, civil disobedience has been utilized as a way to protest against unjust and biased laws, examples of these peaceful protests are sit ins, marches, and hunger strikes. Civil disobedience2 and, as has been said, when it is most expedient, the governed are most let alone by it. On the duty of civil disobedience1 abridged henry david thoreau. It is obvious that the justification of civil disobedience depends upon the theory of political obligation in general, and so we may appropriately begin with a few comments on this question. Civil disobedience is a symbolic or ritualistic violation of the law rather than a rejection of the system as a whole. What are our responsibilities in the face of injustice. Nigeria as a social formation operates a reward system where civil servants and political office holders are.
And any resistance against the sovereign is immoral. But how does one acquire such an obligation, and how many people have really done what is necessary to acquire it. In the second, it is a dangerous act that quickly escalates. In defense of uncivil disobedience dear fellows, my goal in this new project is to conceptualize and make room for the justification of uncivil disobedience. The intent of this document is to show you a sample of a novice case on the civil disobedience topic that incorporates evidence, a value, criterion, and contention level arguments. Civil disobedience and political obligation can the two coexist. Pdf empirically, there are many types of justification of political loyalty. How can we justify from a moral point of view an act of civil d. Civil disobedience essay examples free argumentative.
Civil liberty of the most extensive sort is, therefore, the necessary condition of political obligation and just government. Delmas endorses this right, but wants to add a second and third idea. A theory of civil disobedience in no less than 10 minutes. The purpose of the essay is to develop a more systematic understanding of these concepts, in order to identify more precisely what is at stake in debates of political obligation, civil disobedience, and the authority of law. Social, political, and legal philosophy volume 77 april 1967 number 3 the obligation to disobey. Civil disobedience is the refusal to observe specific laws and is a peaceful way of protest.
When the morality of obedience and disobedience next became a much discussed issue, it was a religious as much as a philosophical discussion. Moreover, we should understand civil disobedience, in the sense of refusal to comply. Civil disobedience the question to be considered in this essay and the next one is whether, and under what circumstances, there is a moral right to break the law for moral or political reasons. Civil government, resolves all civil obligation into expediency. The ld file civil disobedience topic overview part i introduction civil disobedience is generally defined as breaking the laws of a nation, group or any collective in order to persuade the public at large that the law in question is unjust. Liberty must be as extensive as the possible range of consenting action over time and through political space if citizens can conceivably be bound to a strict obedience walzer, 1970. Such command no more respect than men of straw, or a lump of dirt. It is argued that a civil disobedient has an obligation to face the prospect of being punished for the breach of the law. While in jail, gandhi read the essay civil disobedience by henry david thoreau, a 19thcentury american writer. The war with mexico was not declared until 1846, whereas thoreau had refused to pay his tax as early as 1843. First, what is the nature of our political obligation towards the law and the state and, second, what is the relation between law and morality.
The civil disobedient, finding legitimate avenues of change blocked or nonexistent, feels obligated by a higher, extralegal principle to break some specific law. Gandhi and civil disobedience constitutional rights foundation. This chapter discusses civil disobedience and the principles of legal, moral, and political obligation. The nonviolent nature of civil disobedience refers to the fact that it is intended to address the sense of justice of the rnajority and as such it is a form of speech, an expression of conviction. On civil disobedience in recent american democratic thought. It is only when we realize these laws are absolute that we can leave the state of nature. All voting is a sort of gaming, like checkers or backgammon, with a slight moral tinge to it, a playing with. Since government is always an evil, there is a constant obligation to revolt against the state and society. Theorists of political obligation have long devoted special attention to civil disobedience, establishing its pride of place as an object of philosophical analysis, and as one of a short list of exceptions to an otherwise binding obligation to obey the law. The two words from which green formed the phrase are much older, of course, and he apparently thought that combining them required no elaborate. Session 1 rawls, the justification of civil disobedi what. Stettner, wellesley college in a time of disagreement over the legitimacy of american governmental institutions and policies, it is perhaps not coincidental that the twelfth and latest nomos volume1 and several other recent works deal with the topic of political obligation. Famous examples include gandhis salt march in 1930, rosa parkss.
Download pdf civil disobedience and other essays free. The right of civil disobedience is familiar from the political philosophy of john rawls, among others, and the historical example of martin luther king and the campaigns for civil rights in the usa. Freedom, and political obligation, phrases the argu ment in the following way. The essay first assesses recent american analysis of civil disobedience to determine what the criteria should be to distinguish it from other forms of political action and to discover its political ethics. I shall assume that if there is such a moral right then. The status of nonviolence as a necessary component of civil disobedience is questioned, and it is argued that a degree of force or violence may be. Power university of cincinnati theoretical discussions of civil disobedience on ethical and political grounds received special attention in this country during the nuremberg trials, the security and loyalty controversies of the 1950s and the prearms control years of nuclear. Citizens have political obligations, but the obligation to obey the law is not one of them. Political obligation internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Hobbes was against civil disobedience for 2 reasons. I actually debated it for one of the tournaments i did pf, fun times.
Do we justify it when the act itself finds a moral justification from the political obligation point of view or when it. Civil disobedience and the duty to obeyt alexander m. In this paper, rajgopal saikumar examines civil disobedience as a form of resistance to power in contemporary india. As one might be able to guess from the title, the crux of the article is that philosophical questions surrounding civil disobedience are easy questions to answer. Many philosophers argue for what is called political obligationthe duty to obey the law of nearly just, legitimate states. Over the weekend jason brennan published an article at bleeding heart libertarians called a theory of civil disobedience in three minutes. Civil disobedience and political obligation ukessays. Political authority, civil disobedience, revolution a. Civil disobedience is more overtly communicative and political than conscientious objection. When yates openly refused to defend trumps travel ban, she defended the justice departments solemn obligation to always seek justice and stand for what is right. Do we justify it when the act itself finds a moral justification from the political obligation point of view or when it infringes on the life of the individual. On this view, civil disobedience can be justified only when.
When political obligation is overridden, as may be the case in the face of serious injustice, civil disobedience broadly understood as conscientious. Additionally, civil disobedience as a mode of political speech aimed at educating and persuading the public is likely to fall when it involves rude, aggressive, or violent behavior. At the very core of a theory of civil disobedience lie two questions. Standard normative accounts of civil disobedience treat it as a special exemption from ones political obligations. Delmas successfully guides us to reconsider the traditional wisdom of civil disobedience. On a moral right to civil disobedience david lefkowitz. She also makes a strong case for expanding the notion of political obligation, which has been narrowly construed as mere obedience, to encompass a duty to resist.
There are nine hundred and ninetynine patrons of virtue to one virtuous man. On the duty of civil disobedience1 abridged henry david thoreau i heartily accept the motto,that government is best which governs least. Civil disobedience is both a moral theory and a practice, and the two are inseparable. It is a way of justifying certain kinds of political disobedience, but what it involves exactly and its definition have always been derived from what some people have in fact done. Pdf the justification of political obligation researchgate. While delmas contributions to the literature on civil disobedience are obvious, her arguments about political obligation are equally significant. Raz, the authority of law, 262275 a right to dissent. Gandhi adopted the term civil disobedience to describe his strategy of nonviolently refusing to cooperate with injustice, but he preferred the sanskrit word satyagraha devotion to truth.
Populism, violent demonstrations and race civil disobedience. Jan 03, 2018 but for dissenters outside of the administration, civil disobedience is the weapon of choice. Click here to visit my debate academy to get personal coaching, and more. Political obligation is a broad notion and covers many things. One must start a political campaign to reform society. Civil disobedience is often characterized as a conscientious act of illegal protest that people engage in to communicate their opposition to law or government policy. If one takes the view that there is no general moral obligation to follow. Civil disobedience in a democracy is morally justified.
Theories of civil disobedience and nonviolent resistance to. Political obligation might be used to refer to duties by some system of political behaviour stemming from an acknowledged source of political theory. The obligation to obey the law is also supported by a duty of fair play. Civil disobedience and conscientious objection are social practices motivated by moral and political beliefs. Publication date 1972 topics government, resistance to, political obligation publisher new york, crowell. In general, these two practices arise from peoples deeply held commitments. Piero moraro argues that people who engage in civil disobedience do not have a pro tanto reason to accept punishment for breaking the law. By contrast, activists from henry david thoreau to the movement for black lives have long. To engage in violent acts likely to injure and to hurt is incompatible with civil disobedience as a mode of address. If civil disobedience is to be either justified or condemned we. To get back to the founding principles, as articulated in the declaration of independence, zinn argues that we are going to need to go outside the law, to stop obeying the laws that demand killing or that allocate wealth the way it has been done, or. Civil disobedience, climate protests and a rawlsian argument for atmospheric fairness.
1331 325 531 476 138 944 838 1566 304 1245 1015 1194 1167 1473 942 924 216 177 306 1036 325 775 644 122 908 1274 327 232 352